How can you know when a novel is good?
You can’t.
You can know when a novel is finished. (When you’re done writing.)
You can know when a novel is appreciated. (When a reader gives you positive feedback.)
But you can’t know when a novel is good.
You can know when a novel is award-winning. (After it wins an award.)
You can know when a novel is critically-acclaimed. (When a critic acclaims it.)
But you can’t know when a novel is good.
You can know when a novel is funny. (If someone laughs when reading it.)
You can know when a novel has five stars. (After a reviewer clicks the 5-star link.)
But you can’t know when a novel is good.
You can know when a novel is wordy. (After you turn page 500.)
You can know when a novel is boring. (After reading Henry James.)
But you can’t know when a novel is good.
You can know when a novel makes a great movie. (After it’s adapted successfully.)
You can know when a novel has staying power. (When high school English classes start to read it.)
But you can’t know when a novel is good.
You can know when a novel is controversial. (By watching cable news.)
You can know when a novel is not selling. (By looking at its sales ranking.)
But you can’t know when a novel is good.
You can know when a novel is released. (By the date of its release.)
You can know when a novel is a best-seller. (When the New York Times says it is.)
But you can’t know when a novel is good.
So, writers, don’t fret about outcome. Just write. That is always good.
4 responses to “How can you know when a novel is good?”
A sign is when you are still thinking about it a week later 🙂
When I wrote my first novel every time I re-read it I thought something different. I agree. Just enjoy telling the story.
Yes. I remember thinking, “This is good” and then “This is terrible” and then “I’m scared to death to release it” and then … it never ends.
I guess we just have to embrace feelings or give them up. 🙂